Holocaust denialist Whoopi Goldberg regales us once more, with her platitudes on race

HOLOCAUST DENIALIST Whoopi Goldberg has doubled down on her bizarre assertion that the event which reduced a pre-War population of 11 million Jews living in areas controlled by the Nazis to 5 million, was merely ‘white on white violence’.

After issuing an apology for similar statements made on a talk-show programme earlier this year, the Hollywood actress, re-entered the fray as if she had learn absolutely nothing from the previous experience, necessitating yet another retraction.

Goldberg’s latest remarks are deeply offensive and constitute a form of Antisemitism, in which the speaker attributes race to Jews, in order to, yes, make a point about race.

Another dimension is the manner in which the speaker also denies that race-based policies, such as that which existed under the Nazis, are even racist. In effect, decontextualising the Holocaust as nothing more than ‘white privilege’, and is thus a blatant form of denial.

In a new interview with a British newspaper, The Sunday Times shared during Hanukkah, Goldberg showed little remorse for her past rhetoric, ‘arguing again that the estimated 6 million Jews who were systematically killed in the Holocaust were not targeted based on their race’.

“The View” co-host also claimed that the Nazis targeted people of African descent in addition to Jews because they were physically different, and ‘went as far as to suggest that Jews had an easier time blending in with White people and hiding from the Nazis than Black people did at the time of the Holocaust.’

Goldberg suggested “these are two white groups of people. The minute you turn it into race, it goes down this alley. Let’s talk about it for what it is. It’s how people treat each other.” You can read my earlier comments and response to this statement here.

Whoopi’s comments are not simply illogical and wrong-headed, but could mislead one to conclude that black persons such as herself, cannot experience racism.

Race is the child of racism not the father. The issue here is not whether “Jews are divided on whether they are a race, religion or both” or perceive themselves to be a race (they don’t) but whether the Nazis did.

For the record, the Jews for the most part, form an historical community much like the Kurds, in which ethnicity plays a part, however there are many sub-communities, and thus one may discern Haredi, Sephardi, Ashkenazi and Mizrahi or Oriental Jews.

Local news-outlets such as IOL have failed to cover this story since it exposes and thus jars with the obvious attempt to decontextualise the Holocaust in order to provide a different narrative to the Israel/Palestine conflict, one in which the tragic genocide never occurred.

UPDATE: IOL are now carrying Whoopi’s second apology and retraction.

South Africa’s Holocaust Denial hearings

Prof Milton Shain gives evidence

Eva Schloss is pretty much insulted by the contents of a Radio 786 broadcast made in 1998 in which all Jews,  every single last one, are targeted by racist Anti-Semitic invective which denies the injustice of the Holocaust at the same time that it appears to urge a similar solution to the “Jewish Problem”.

I attended three days of the hearings into the Radio 786 Holocaust Denial case in which experts, academics and witnesses to the tragedy presented evidence.

Eva Schloss is a beautiful woman, who was just nine when Austria was annexed, and her entire family were forced to clean pavements with tooth brushes, she still has a tattooed number on her arm from where the Nazi’s registered her when the war finally caught up after her family fled to Holland. Frau Schloss’s father, brother and step-sister Anne Frank were all murdered by the Nazis.

“I have seen the real and terrible harm caused by anti-Semitic media statements like those contained in the broadcast” she told the commission.

“After May 1940…the trouble started for the Jews. Our freedom was severely restricted by a series of anti-Jewish decrees: Jews were required to wear a yellow star; Jews were required to turn-in their bicycles; Jews were forbidden to ride trams or in cars, even their own…Jews were forbidden to go to theatres, cinemas or any other forms of entertainment; Jews were forbidden to use swimming pools, tennis courts, hockey fields or any other athletic fields…You couldn’t do this and you couldn’t do that, but life went on…”

Do we really have to examine such propositions as the advocacy of genocide — hate speech such as the denial of the Holocaust? Why should the burden of proof be placed on the victims and survivors of a crime against humanity? See: Holocaust denial is hateful, immoral and factually wrong

Think of people who were tortured and placed in solitary confinement, do we have to expose them to cross-examination on issues of credibility, every time some person claiming to be an academic, comes up with the preposterous notion that intellectually speaking, we cannot actually prove the existence of history?

Radio 786 argument seems to be along the lines of “we have the right to freedom of speech no matter what and we shouldn’t be bound by the Constitution which expressly outlaws hate speech.”

And hence the misleading media statements being issued, while the station’s own council accept the errant mischief intended by a broadcast with no attempt to solicit moderation from experts or the Jewish community itself, a spokesperson, supposedly reported in Friday’s Cape Times says in effect: We will never, ever, apologise for spreading malicious lies.

On Thursday, the leaders of South Africa’s mostly Orthodox Jewish community offered to accept an apology and walk away. Instead, South Africans were greeted with renewed claims and an attempt to defend the indefensible. Hate media was found to be a significant contributing factor in the Rwandan Genocide.

Time to revoke the license of Radio 786?

Mahmoud Ahmadinejad a true post-modernist, or just crazy?

Been thinking about the problem with Mahmoud. Perhaps we should be putting up “I love Mahmoud Ahmadinejad” signs and calling for him to surrender to the infinite virtue and forgiveness of the universe. Then when he’s not looking, pack him off to the funny farm?

Not only does Mahmoud Ahmadinejad think that he is GOD, he is literally GOD. Quite obviously. I am waiting for the next sura to emanate from his very lips. The metaphysical truth – There was no Holocaust. The 20th Century is a myth. How very postmodern. I know a few people who sound like him sometimes, most of them are nuts.

Obviously if he was actually ON, speaking the TRUTH, he would be saying: There was NOTHING and there was EVERYTHING. THE HOLOCAUST MEANS NOTHING AND IT MEANS EVERYTHING at least from an existential perspective.

Mahmoud Ahmadinejad the all-powerful, all-knowing and all-seeing. Mahmoud the TRUTH. The unmoved mover, the causeless cause of all causes. GOD on EARTH. Surely the man is immortal? Able to prove to us his indestructible nature? I say, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad can stop a bullet with his teeth?

Virtues ascribed to the Prophet Mohemmed, which can be ascribed to Mahmoud Ahmadinejad – a man of good lineage, clear conscience, able to pass the various tests put to him. Let’s test him now.