John Pilger’s Truth variations

IN 1945 the Allies bombed the German city of Desden. In four raids between 13 and 15 February 1945, British Royal Air Force (RAF) and United States Army Air Forces (USAAF) dropped more than 3,900 tons of high-explosive bombs and incendiary devices on the city. The bombing and the resulting firestorm destroyed over 6.5 km2 of Dresden, resulting in the deaths of between 22,700 and 25,000 people.

In August of 2014  the Israel Defense Force (IDF) bombed Gaza City, toppling the 15-storey Basha Tower and destroying a power plant and infrastructure. Some 2000 Gazans including women and children were killed in the conflict sparked by Hamas missile attacks against Israel in an escalation of violence caused by the kidnapping of three Israeli seminary students.

For holocaust revisionists such as John Pilger and Ilan Pappe, Dresden isn’t an act of genocide, yet this years repetition and sequel to the 2008-2009 Operation Cast Lead has all the overtones of mass slaughter and carnage synonymous with the term, once associated with the targeting of a particular national or ethnic group, in what has become a familiar indictment by Hamas apologists and those seeking the destruction of the Jewish State:

Israel is guilty of ethnic cleansing, genocide and worse, promoting, “permissible genocide”.

Far be it for me to support either of these tragic positions, articulated in the above two examples: War is not the solution to human problems. Nelson Mandela showed South Africans and the world that dialogue and listening to the other person’s point of view, are far better weapons in the struggle for human rights.

Mandela’s bipartisanship and non-sectarian approach to the issue of apartheid South Africa extended to his position on the Middle East, which he articulated as follows: “As a movement, we recognise the legitimacy of Palestinian nationalism just as we recognise the legitimacy of Zionism as a Jewish nationalism. We insist on the right of the state of Israel to exist within secure borders but with equal vigour support the Palestinian right to national self-determination.”

It is thus with a sense of moral outrage and indignation at the rapid loss of Mandela’s unique perspective and the problem of equivocation on Dresden (why is the Holocaust considered a Genocide but the fire-bombing of German cities doesn’t rate?) and also concern for the consequences for world peace if we fail to learn from history and fail to debate such issues–  that I raise some uncomfortable facts regarding the Axis forces responsible for the extermination of 6 million Jews, and the ethnic cleansing of Jewish Palestinians under Hitler’s Final Solution.

Pilger in a polemic piece published by the Sunday Times, claims to raise the problem of Ben Gurion’s Plan D and the Siege of Jerusalem which resulted in the displacement of people on either side to the conflict during the Israeli War of Independence, In doing so, he painfully ignores the problem of Nazi atrocities committed in Jerusalem under the rule of Haj Amin al-Husseini.

During World War II al-Husseini collaborated with both Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy, recruiting Muslims for the Waffen-SS and sending some 100 000 Jerusalem Jews to gas chambers in the Ukraine.

In February 1941, al-Husseini submitted to the Nazi German Government a draft declaration of German-Arab cooperation, containing a clause:

Germany and Italy recognize the right of the Arab countries to solve the question of the Jewish elements, which exist in Palestine and in the other Arab countries, as required by the national and ethnic (völkisch) interests of the Arabs, and as the Jewish question was solved in Germany and Italy.

Encouraged by his meeting with the Italian leader, al-Husseini prepared a draft declaration, affirming the Axis support for the Arabs on 3 November. In three days, the declaration, slightly amended by the Italian foreign ministry, received the formal approval of Mussolini and was forwarded to the German embassy in Rome. On 6 November, al-Husseini arrived in Berlin, where he discussed the text of his declaration with Ernst von Weizsäcker and other German officials. In the final draft, which differed only marginally from al-Husseini’s original proposal, the Axis powers declared their readiness to approve the elimination (Beseitigung) of the Jewish National Home in Palestine.

Haj Amin al-Husseini meeting with Adolf Hitler (December 1941).

On 20 November, al-Husseini met the German Foreign Minister Joachim von Ribbentrop and was officially received by Adolf Hitler on 28 November. He asked Adolf Hitler for a public declaration that ‘recognized and sympathized with the Arab struggles for independence and liberation, and that would support the elimination of a national Jewish homeland’.

Hitler refused to make such a public announcement, saying that it would strengthen the Gaullists against Vichy France, but asked al-Husseini to ‘to lock …deep in his heart’ the following points, which Christopher Browning summarizes as follows, that:

‘Germany has resolved, step by step, to ask one European nation after the other to solve its Jewish problem, and at the proper time, direct a similar appeal to non-European nations as well’. When Germany had defeated Russia and broken through the Caucasus into the Middle East, it would have no further imperial goals of its own and would support Arab liberation… But Hitler did have one goal. “Germany’s objective would then be solely the destruction of the Jewish element residing in the Arab sphere under the protection of British power”. (Das deutsche Ziel würde dann lediglich die Vernichtung des im arabischen Raum unter der Protektion der britischen Macht lebenden Judentums sein). In short, Jews were not simply to be driven out of the German sphere but would be hunted down and destroyed even beyond it.’

Al-Husseini meeting with Muslim Waffen SS volunteers,

When Hitler expounded his view that the Jews were responsible for World War I, Marxism and its revolutions, and this was why the task of Germans was to persevere in a battle without mercy against the Jews, al-Hussein is said to have replied: “We Arabs think that Zionism, not the Jews, is the cause of all of these acts of sabotage.”

In December 1942, al-Husseini held a speech at the celebration of the opening of the Islamic Central Institute (Islamische Zentralinstitut) in Berlin, of which he served as honorary chair. In the speech, he harshly criticised those he considered as aggressors against Muslims, namely “Jews, Bolsheviks and Anglo-Saxons.”

At the time of the opening of the Islamic Central Institute, there were an estimated 3,000 Muslims in Germany, including 400 German converts. The Islamic Central Institute gave the Muslims in Germany institutional ties to the ‘Third Reich’  thus securing Nazi support for the Arab league.

In the propaganda war being waged by both sides, it is important to note the issue of proportionality. Clearly, as Pilger demonstrates, the use of emotive terms such as “Genocide” and “Ethnic Cleansing” fail to take into account the historical legacy of Arab support for Hitler’s Final Solution and the responsibility which Arab Palestinians must bear in their support of the extermination of Jews. Our freedom is not complete without the freedom of the Palestinians according to Mandela, and as a secularist he would also have added: this freedom is meaningless if it fails to include Judaism, Islam and Christianity.

Leave a Reply